Friday, November 14, 2008

SOME MORE QUESTIONS

Circa 1946, Mohd. Ali Jinnah was steamrolling his opposition and humanity with his drive for Pakistan. Kashmir was of special interest to Jinnah because of its majority population of Muslims and most importantly its strategic importance. But Jammu and Kashmir which was under the reign of Maharaja Hari Singh was lorded over by another strongman Sheikh Abdullah of the National Conference. Jinnah inspite of his best efforts failed to win over Sheikh Abdullah, and true to his style, launched a vitriolic attack on him, "this man tells me that he is on my side, but when he goes out he calls himself a nationalist. He cannot be trusted." Maybe Jinnah had been pampered by the indulgence of the Congress leaders. But the Sheikh was no Congressman. He retaliated in good measure, "Jinnah is not even a Muslim, he cannot recite a single Kalima from the Quran."


Jinnah faced massive protests wherever he went in Kashmir. In Baramulla,a young National Conference worker Maqbool Sherwani presented Jinnah with a massive garland. The moment Jinnah was about to board his vehicle Sherwani took off the cover of the garland. To Jinnnah's horror the garland was entirely made up of an assortment of footwear. Jinnah immediately left for Rawalpindi.


But evidently Jinnah did not forget this humiliation. For a few months later when the 'tribals' who in reality were the Pakistani army in mufti, launched their incursion, Baramulla faced the brunt. Even the churches were not spared as the missionary sisters were raped and murdered enmasse.What became of the Hindu and Sikh women who had taken shelter there, is a story which was never known.


The Pakistanis after capturing Baramulla were only 30 kms. away from the Srinagar Airport. Maharaja Hari Singh had acceded to India and the Indian forces were on their way. The Srinagar Airport had to be kept free for the Indian forces which had already started landing, but were miniscule compared to the numerical strength of the Pakistanis.

Time was of essence.


Maqbool Sherwani, now pretending to act as an informer promised to show the Pakistanis a shortcut to the Airport.Leading the convoy on his motorcycle he took them on a merry go around and ensured that they lost their way.


The Indian Army took full use of this opportunity and Jammu and Kashmir was saved.


But Maqbool was not.


He was crucified by the infiltrators on an electric pole in Baramulla town by driving nails through his body. He was subsequently brought down in a hail of bullets. Maqbool Sherwani became a martyr for the sake of the nation. Mahatma Gandhi paid tributes to Maqbool Sherwani in his evening prayer meeting.


The Indian Army performed heroic deeds in that campaign, General Thimmaya took his tanks to a height where tanks had not gone before. Hannibal would have been proud. Major Somnath Sharma earned the first Param Vir Chakra in the Indian army during that campaign. That our leaders lost what Maqbool or Major Sharma became martyrs for is besides the point.


What hurts is that were we even educated about the martyrdom of people like Maqbool Sherwani? (I myself read about this supreme sacrifice in an article by a retired army officer, recently.) Or maybe that is what our political elite wanted. For martyrdom has become the preserve of a selected few who rake it for political gains. Elections have been fought over the dead bodies of 'martyrs',with the opponents not even fathoming how to react.That there was a difference between 'martyrdom' and 'political assassination' is well,.... again besides the point.


Today no political leader visits the grave of Maqbool Sherwani is a fact which needs no corroboration. The fact that accusatory fingers were raised at the martyrdom of Inspector M.C. Sharma at the Batla House encounter is an indirect corroborative evidence that this country gives a damn to people who go beyond their call of duty. Even the National Security Advisor M.K.Narayanan has endorsed the authenticity of the encounter but the fact is still not sufficient for some, or so it seems.


The country is today witness to the shameful spectacle to the attempt to denigrate the prestige of the Indian army, subsequent to the arrest of Lt.Col. Purohit by the Anti Terrorist Squad of the Maharashtra Police for his alleged involvement in the Malegaon blast. All and sundry have joined in, albeit subtly. The Indian army, perhaps the only institution which can truly claim to be Secular, which puts duty before self, an institution which is in the vanguard of fighting terrorism, fighting floods, fighting communal riots, fighting the aftermath of earthquake, saving children from their falls into open borewells, has an additional fight at its hand. It has to prove its Secular credentials to the politicians duly abetted by its lackey,in this case the police.


The entire saga started with the arrest of Sadhvi Pragya Singh Thakur, whose Motor Cycle was allegedly used to implant bombs in Malegaon resulting in the death of 5 people. The ATS should be commended for its prompt investigation, especially in view of the fact that not much headway has been made by it in the Malegaon blast of 2006 in which 37 people were killed, apart from the arrest of some SIMI activists or the Mumbai blasts of 2006.


The electronic media is having a field day in covering this investigation, 'HINDU TERROR' says one channel in the background of its presentation, which anyway is saturated. The discussion revolves around how Hindus are also becoming terrorists. Now the ATS is also investigating the involvement of Purohit and Sadhvi in the Samjhauta express blast a few years back, the Nanded blast investigation is being reopened. The way things are proceeding do not be surprised to see the WTC attack, the Mumbai blast of 2006 also being credited to these motley bunch of people. One Dayanand Pandey, an apparently self styled guru has been picked up . The credit of being the 'mastermind' is changing every day. The best part of the investigation pertains to the fact that it appears that the entire interrogation is being performed in front of these busybodies from the news channels. Some body in the ATS is leaking worse than the sinking Titanic, for reasons not for us to conjecture upon. Somebody please remind the ATS guys of discrete investigation being in their professional call of duty . Or is there more to the investigation than meets the eye?

Praveen Swami in THE HINDU, has gone a step ahead and done a complete analysis of the genesis of 'Hindu Terrorism', notwithstanding the fact that certain literature which was used during the freedom struggle has been selectively interpreted. These people are not far from branding Khudiram Bose and Prafulla Chaki at par with the goons from Jaish-e-Mohd and Lashkar-e-Taiba.


Incidentally, a few weeks ago, our friends from the media were stressing upon the need to delink terrorism from religion and stuff like Islam not sanctioning acts of terrorism. Now words like 'HINDU TERROR' are casually being bandied about. My congratulations to these media guys. But please feel free to use the epithet of 'Muslim Terrorism' next time Muslim Terrorists attack a predominantly Hindu India, in order to follow norms of fairplay and avoid accusations of double standards.


Congratulations again on succeeding in dividing terrorists into Hindu and Muslims. It is the mindless urge like this to increase TRP ratings which provides criminals of all hues ammunition to incite fellow criminals, my dear friends, but do we really care? For years our media friends justified acts of terror as 'revenge for Gujarat riots' or 'revenge for the Babri Masjid demolition' and castigated people like L.K.Advani, Narendra Modi, RSS, more than the terrorists themselves. Drawing on the same analogy of revenge can a Hindu child/youth affected by acts of terrorism not seek revenge from the people he feels to be behind the acts of terror ? Any answers ? An act of terror is an act against humanity irrespective of the logic behind it and so it should have been, but in our yearning for votes, sale of books, acceptability amongst the pseudo liberal media, look at the mess we have gotten into.


One issue is intriguing and maybe the ATS or anyone else will clear the air on this. Apparently the motor cycle of Sadhvi Pragya Singh Thakur was used to place explosives in Malegaon, the discovery of which has led to these arrests. If the same is true then it must act as a disgrace to the tribe of the criminals, since you are not supposed to leave any evidence at the scene of the crime, let alone using explosives on your own motorcycle. How disingenuous!! If an armyman, who also worked for the Military intelligence, was also part of this naivety, then I call upon the govt. to disband the Military Intelligence unit ........our ATS guys do better.



But we as a country do not want questions but only answers, therefore the 'Army is getting communal' , 'Hindu Terror', 'Save Afzal Guru' campaign prevails over logic and reasoning. For example any answers to the fact that any bombing attack needs months of meticulous planning even for trained army personnel, an organisation, training, reconnaissance missions. If the motley, unconnected group of people such as the accused in the Malegaon blast could carry it off, then only God can save us from the Al Qaida and its friends.

Let us not forget the sacrifice made by unsung heroes like Maqbool Sherwani and Major Som Nath Sharma for the unity and integrity of the nation. Our politicians might stop eulogising them but let us pay our respect to these real heroes by not dividing terrorists into Hindu terrorists or Muslim Terrorists and damaging the interest of the nation. A Terrorist is a terrorist and should be dealt by the rule of law. Elections might come and elections might go, but the country and its institutions remain.

The Indian Army remains awake so that we can sleep. Let us not denigrate the brave sons of the soil for the sake of a few votes.

JAI HIND.

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

FORUM OF WHISTLE BLOWERS OF INDIA
Association of Fearless, Courageous, Intelligent, Honest, Citizens with Vision, Credibility & Integrity
Fighting against Corruption in India is like Committing Suicide. - We are one of them.-Join Us
Patron: Mr. D.R.Patel President: Dr.R.K.D.Goel Secretary: Mr.S.N.Raha Convenor: Mr.R.M.Jingar
Ph: 2655993 Ph: 2647677 Ph: 2654710 Ph: 2638797
1414-A, Akashdeep Soc, b/h Akaswani, Makarpura Rd.Vadodara-390 009 E-mail: rkdgoel@aol.com
WITH
ASSOCIATION OF RESIDENTS OF SOCIETIES FROM DANDIA BAZAR TO MKARPURA


This above Photo shows how the refugees travelled from Punjab (Now Pakistan) to India after / before partition of India in AUGUST, 1947.

I, as the RSS worker at the age of 10 years served day and night food articles to my hindu brothers / sisters / mothers at Muzaffarnagar (UP) Rly. station when these trains passes through our city.

IN 1947 RSS WORKERS OF JAMMU SAVED KASHMIR / INDIA FROM THE INVASION OF PAKISTAN AND MARCHING OF MUJAHIDEEN / PATHANS IN SRINAGAR. IF RSS WORKERS WOULD NOT HAVE DID SACRIFICE, WHOLE INDIA WOULD HAVE BEEN PAKISTAN AND PAKISTANI FLAG WILL BE FLYING ON LAL KILLA OF DELHI.

PRESENT YOUNG RSS WORKERS / BJP POLITICIANS IN POWER BORN AFTER 1950, TELL WHAT ARE THEIR SACRIFICE / CONTRIBUTIONS FOR FREEDOM OF INDIA?
WHAT SELFLESS SERVICE THEY DID / DOING IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF BHARAT MATA?

WE SHOULD MAINTAIN COMMUNAL HARMONY SO THAT TERRORISTS THOSE CALLED THEMSELVES “INDIAN MUJAHIDEEN“ SHOULD NOT HARM US BY BOMB BLASTS IN INDIA.

LET US MAKE VADODARA A LIVING CITY OF ITS OLD GLORY “SANSKAR NAGRI”

Dr.R.K.D.GOEL,
72 YEARS OLD. Now settled in Vadodara (Gujarat)

Bobby said...

The Sixth pay commission report has raised the resentment of the armed forces and now this witch hunt. Punish the guilty by all means but please do not denigrate an institution for they are extremely hard to build. And there has to be some remedy to this trial by media. It started with the Arushi Talwar case and continues in the instant case. Do these people even imagine the damage to the credibility of a person caused by hearsay. As I referred to in the post,some officer in the ATS is leaking worse than the Titanic and with a conduct like this, can the integrity of this entire exercise be trustworthy?
Referring to terrorism as Hindu Terror is a despicable act at par with Musharraf calling the terrorists in Kashmir as freedom fighters and the ones in Afghanistan or Pakistan as terrorist. A terrorist is a terrorist, PERIOD. But then what would a small man like me know?
My regards to Dr. Goel as he appears to be fighting corruption in his own way.Perhaps he would like to share more about his organisation for the readers to know. I agree that fighting corruption is like committing suicide, so strongly has it become entrenched in the society. I personally know one individual who took it head on in the paramilitary forces and is now being harassed to no end. A pity isn't it?

Bobby said...

Misar told the court on Saturday that Purohit (39) had handed over 60 kg RDX to one person identified as Bhagwan who used it for the Samjhauta blast. "A witness told us that Purohit had 60 kg RDX in his possession while posted in Deolali, Nashik. He had to deposit the explosive at the army's artillery department in Jammu and Kashmir. However, Purohit told our witness that he had not deposited the explosive with the army and instead told them that he had threw it into the Jhelum river in J&K. He later gave the RDX to a person named Bhagwan who used it in the Samjhauta train bomb blast," Misar had told chief judicial magistrate H K Gantra while seeking an extension in Purohit's police custody.
THE ABOVE IS THE STATEMENT OF THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR BEFORE THE JUDICAL MAGISTRATE WHILE SEEKING EXTENSION OF LT.COL.PUROHITS'S CUSTODY AS REPORTED IN THE TIMES OF INDIA . 60 KGS. OF RDX MIND YOU! IN THE GUYS' PERSONAL POSSESSION AND HE THEN THROWS IT IN THE JHELUM AND THEN SOMEHOW RECOVERS IT AND THEN USES IT TO ATTACK THE SAMJHAUTA EXPRESS TO WHICH THE SIMI CHIEF SAFDAR NAGORI HAD ALSO PURPORTEDLY OWNED UP A FEW MONTHS BACK. WILL THE ATS PLEASE LEAK THE REAL TRUTH FOR THIS GAME HAS DANGEROUS REPURCUSSIONS BEYOND THE UPCOMING ASSEMBLY AND PARLIAMENTARY ELECTIONS.
ALSO NOTICE THE FACT THAT THE ARMY CONDUCTS NO ENQUIRY FOR THE MISSING RDX. OR IS THE WHOLE INDIAN ARMY A HINDU TERRORIST ORGANISATION? THE PROPAGANDA COULD NOT HAVE BEEN BETTER CARRIED OUT BY THE ISI.
PUNISH THE GUILTY BY ALL MEANS, BUT ATLEAST INVESTIGATE COMPLETELY.
INTERESTINGLY EVEN UNDER THE RTI ACT EXEMPTION IS PROVIDED FROM DISCLOSING INFORMATION WHICH WOULD IMPEDE THE PROCESS OF INVESTIGATION OR APPREHENSION OR PROSECUTION OFOFFENDERS. BUT THE ATS IS EXEMPT FROM ALL NORMS OF CONSTITUTION IT APPEARS, AND CAN CONDUCT AN INTERROGATION IN FULL PUBLIC VIEW, SO AS TO KEEP THE TV CHANNELS RUNNING.
NOW THE EX GOV. OF J&K S.K.SINHA (ALSO EX DEPUTY CHIEF OF ARMY) WHO WAS ALWAYS A POTENTIAL TARGET OF THE TERRORISTS FOR HIS UNFLINCHING ATTITUDE IN ASSAM AND J&K IS BEING DRAGGED INTO THIS MUD BY NONE OTHER THAN THE GREAT MUFTI MOHD. SAYED BECAUSE HE APPARENTLY HOSTED DAYANAND PANDEY.THEREFORE HE ALSO BECOMES A HINDU TERRORIST. HOW THE SAME MUFTI HAD BECOME THE C.M OF J&K BY ELICITING THE OVERT SUPPORT OF THE PATRIOTS OF THE LASHKAR IS NOBODY'S CASE REALLY!!!

Anonymous said...

I agree at least on one point that the 'Free Media'(Whatever that means)is doing a great harm to the country.
Regarding the Army,corruption has also crept in their rank and files like in all walks of life.Whether Purohit is guilty or not it is too premature to deduce.
The Maths and Madarsas are no longer associated with true religion.Just look into the eyes of any Shankrachrya or Imams,you will find only reflection of bloated egos.
Even after 60 plus years of Independence we have not matured as a country.Why blame the politicians only when we all are contributing in our own way for the 'mess'in which we are in.
Solution-The country needs a KODA SHASHAN(Please don't mistake it with Madhu Koda)at least for a decade.

Esoteric Realms said...

Bobby, the note on Maqbool Sherwani and Major Somnath Sharma are eye openers ! Especially Maqbool Sherwani !
Mufti Mohd. Syeed is the same politician for whose daughter (Rubaiya Sayeed) terrorists were exchanged for the first time in history of India.
The issue raised by you abt ATS trying to have a trial by media....though true....gives one a feeling of utter helplessness....to see the whole nation being torn to bits by the politicians for their own vested interests. Very thoughtful write up chief.

Anonymous said...

Koda Shashan as mentioned by Vipin is not necessarily the only solution.Look at Pakistan,Myanmaar or many other countries whose development graph is much below India and they rank very high on corruption scale.

Anonymous said...

Please don't co-relate 'Koda Shashan' with dictatorship.Dictatorship per se has not contributed to development of any country.What we need is strict administration ,like in Singapore.

Unknown said...

Singapore is an example of enlightened democracy with a single party system but a single party in India!! Unimaginable. Anyway the idea is good, but who will bell the cat?
I have been noticing the letters to the editor in the newspapers in the past few weeks. Suddenly there is a spurt in Muslim writers regarding the ATS probe and not one calls for an opportunity to the accused or a fair investigation and not hanging the accused before the trial. Compare the attitude of the Hindus when instances of Muslim terrorism (Now I will call it muslim terrorism) took place. There were equal number who asked for a fair investigation and not painting the religion per se with terrorism. I myself feel distresed writing about such frivolous issues but the sudden silence of terrorists throughout the country is eerie. It is as if they have achieved the motive of diverting the focus from their nefarious designs.
And yes I am waiting for the day when the ATS implicates Lt. Col. Purohit with the ISI. This is called Indian style of gratitude towards our patriots.

Shikha said...

I have been wondering about how this whole "Hindu terror" thing seems to be getting resolved so fast by people who have made zilch headway in terrorism that has been killing our contrymen for so many years.

This is very insightful.

And I agree that matryrs in our counrty are like commodities to be sold - like everything else. There is little that's left untouched by selfish motives of people.

Bobby said...

The ATS is loosing its credibility with the manner it is conducting the invsetigation and selectively leaking information. The offshoot of this slipshod investigation will that whatever happens to this investigation, future investigations will also be taken be with a pinch of salt, but then who cares? Meawhile CNN IBN has started referring to the investigation as saffron terror, but for all the pretence of journalism, freedom of press, and creative liberty never was the thousands of the 'other' attacks called Green or Crescent terror. The damage these people are causing to the country will be irreparable but then again, WHO CARES? Not the common man atleast!